The group went into hiatus for six months when Lindsay left and Stevie and Nic joined the Gadflys. In June 1985, the band reformed (adding ex-Gadflys’ drummer Peter Velzen) and this line-up released their debut single “Strange Affection” on their own label Rattlesnake Records. The group moved to Melbourne in October and added Andy Lewis on keyboards, guitar and harmony vocals. They released two cassettes, No Era Is Safe and Half A Cow, both in 1986.

By the end of 1986, they relocated to Sydney. Andy Lewis left the band in 1987. In June 1988 they issued their debut five-track mini-album, Trust Us, which was produced by Charlie Owen on the Green Fez label. They followed in November with another single, “I Don’t Mind”, produced by Rob Younger. In January 1989 Pillage was replaced on drums by Geoff Milne (ex-Eastern Dark). The group issued their next single, “I Didn’t Even See Them at All”, in June 1989 on Citadel Records. In March the following year they issued another five-track mini-album, Sarah’s not Falling in Love, which was produced by Younger. In September another single, “Christo”, appeared, which was followed in July the next year by a four-track mini-album, Home Movie, produced by Younger.

In 1989 Hippy Dribble was formed as a side project with Dalton as Nic Dribble, Milne as Geoff Dribble and Plunder as Stevie Dribble. Hippy Dribble played psychedelic pop and issued a four-track extended play, Wild Strawberri, in November 1990 on their own Trip Records label. The trio formed another side project, Captain Denim, in December 1990 to play “more laid-back songs mostly from the very early Plunderers days when they were influenced by the likes of Buffalo Springfield, Country & Western and folk rock”.

In 1992, Dalton joined US band the Lemonheads and Lewis and Plunder formed the Whitlams so the band was put on a break. Releases still flowed: Citadel released a compilation cd called Banana Smoothie, Honey, the band self-released an eight-track live album, 13.7.91 Live! Live! Live!

Hippy Dribble released another four-track EP, Cheerleader, on Dalton’s own label, Half a Cow. In April that year, Hippy Dribble resumed and issued a split album: their side is Silver Apples; while Captain Denim is on the other side with Fade; on the Half a Cow label. The material had been recorded four years earlier by the line-up of Dalton, Milne and Plunder.

On 25 January 1996, Stevie Plunder took his own life at Wentworth Falls in the Blue Mountains, at the age of 32 years. The Plunderers would be no more after this event. On 12 February 2000 Andy Lewis also took his own life. He was 33.

In November 2000 Half A Cow re-issued Banana Smoothie, Honey as a double CD format with five bonus tracks originally released by Hippy Dribble or Captain Denim. Nic says: “The Plunderers kept saving our songs for our first album. Stevie Plunder died and we never got to record an album – my single biggest regret regarding music. We had all these great songs that were never recorded”.

*Not to be confused with the 1960s garage pop band 'The Plunderers'.